| Codes/Comments (Bakker) | Codes/Comments (Paris) | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
020c - hatredI am so sorry your precious little boy died. There is no justice in his death, and the pain is excruciating, isn't it. I can relate to the pain of having the damage this experience can do to a person's spirituality. The death of my daughter Salome ripped up my faith like paper shredder, a faith I was proud of, and which I thought was strong enough and 'mature' enough to get through everything. That in itself has for me been one of the major things to grieve in all of this mess.
I am 2 years on now, and my faith is by no means sorted. In Salome's eulogy I said I was no longer on speaking terms with God. I have shifted from that posiiton, but it's still a long hard road and I wish it wasn't. Here's a blogpost I wrote back when I was about 4 months out from Salome's death, for your interest: I hope you are surrounded by people who can support you and can listen without trying to shush you up or try to pack your feelings or thoughts back in a box. For me, I think there is nothing blasphemous in asking questions and / or showing your fury to God. I mean God knows about it already, right? Wishing you peace. I have always found the anger a very DRAINING part of the grief. In some ways there is an energy to it, but it's draining too. |
1 |
| 1 |
020d - going to be a rough weekAnonymouse I am so terribly sorry to read that this baby has died. How agonising for you and your family. I'll be thinking of you over the weekend particularly with the induction immanent. I would offer to pray for you, but I am afraid I am still not on speaking terms with God myself. You will be very much in my thoughts though and I am sending you supportive vibes, for what it's worth |
1 |
| 1, 2 |
020e - calling all parents of rainbow/Phoenix babiesI don’t have time to write a coherent post, due to lack of sleep etc. Please find below some unconnected comments about how life is here for me at the moment. I was just wondering if any of it rings a bell for anyone else. All comments welcome.... It’s almost 18 months since our gorgeous Salome dies, and our son Jonah is now 12 weeks old. Jonah is a good sleeper and a calm little bloke so we are through the high-pressure bit of life with a new born. But now I’m out of crisis mode I’m feeling a lot more difficult stuff than I was before. There is a back log of things to be grieved that I haven’t had the emotional space to look at until now, and as the immediate baby-pressure has decreased, these Other Things to be Grieved are coming up out of the mud. Number 1 on the Other Things to be Grieved list is the loss of my faith. Previously Christian in form and Catholic in brand, my faith has been absolutely shredded by the last 18 months. I am very sad about this, and angry too. It’s made extra tricky by my dh having the opposite experience: the death of our daughter has deepened his faith which has been a source of strength and comfort to him. So there are 2 aspects to that one: the loss of my faith and then also the effect of that on our relationship. Our paths have diverged at this point and sadly our faith is something we no longer share. Since our daughter’s death, dh has started another tertiary course in theology, and I have trouble even walking into a church. As if our marriage has not been under enough pressure already.... Ironically, since Salome’s death I am more sure than ever that a sacred dimension of life exists. It’s just that I have yet to meet a God whose team I’d like to be on. And I am fed up with feeling so spiritually adrift. ... |
1, 2 |
| 1 |
020f - new week, Jan. 17AFM, week 24. We've come back from a Christian conference thingy my husband helped organised. Until now I have been thinking of myself as a Christian going through hard times. I've realised over the last few days that I am instead occupying a sort of demilitarised zone between 'Christian going through hard times' and 'No longer Christian'. That's sad, just one more thing to grieve from this whole shitty mess, and it's a big one. |
1 |
| 3 |
021a - PerfectMy husband's grandmother alluded to the same thing--something like, "God has a plan and there must have been some reason for this." I don't know if she meant a specific physical reason or what, but I bristled at it because it sounded just like the kind of words I remember people saying when I was younger and one of my cousins had a miscarriage, words I accepted at the time but now I completely disagree with: "These things happen for a reason... there must have been something wrong with the baby..." When we got the autopsy report and there was no identifiable cause of death for my daughter and everything stupid thing on that list was marked "normal," I was devastated but I also felt sort of vindicated. Here I held scientific "proof" my baby was perfect (except for the no-heartbeat part). But now I see that was wrong, too. Because even if there had been something "abnormal," even if there had been a chromosomal problem or a physical deformity or a specific problem with her heart, had my baby lived (and many babies do), no one would have dared say that she was less than perfect. Perfection isn't some kind of universal standard--it's the measure of how much she was loved and wanted and cherished. To suggest that any baby, whatever the circumstances, is not automatically perfect in the eyes of those who love her, it's nothing less than unbelievably rude. To try to dress it up in the guise of condolences is cruel. I know that our babies were perfect. By anyone's standards. Besides that, your baby girl was wanted and loved just the way she was. And that automatically makes her perfect. I'm not sure I would have been quick enough to say something in that moment, either--reflexes are slow when you've just been flattened by grief! But if it would make you feel better to send an e-mail or letter later on, don't hesitate to tell this friend how her words made you feel and how wrong she is about the claims she made. I agree with Mandy S.--she's looking for a way to make the world make sense. But random, terrible things happen to perfect babies and to good mothers all the time. It doesn't make any sense at all. We just do the best we can to create our own meaning out of what we end up with. I am so sorry about the loss of your perfect daughter. My heart goes out to you. You're not alone in this--in feeling the grief or being insulted by well-meaning people. Hang in there. |
3 |
|
3, 4 wanting to dissuade people in her community about hurtful or offensive or insensitive notions of God; searching for a way to view God's work in the world that is loving rather than cruel |
021b - how do you deal with friends having babies?The God's Will thing is so yicky. The only person who said such a thing to me was my husband's grandmother. I understand that it is partly her way of coping, but I made myself feel better by sending her a copy of Rabbi Kushner's book "When Bad Things Happen to Good People." He talks about the possibility of a God that is infinitely good but perhaps not in charge of everything that happens--the difference between random fate and God's goodness. I'm still feeling pretty neutral about the whole God thing, but I just had to do something to show her that I don't believe in a God who steals people's babies and there are other ways to think about why tragedy occurs besides the fact that God wanted it to happen. Someone else said to me that God wouldn't want anyone to suffer this--after all, he knows what it is like to have your child die. And speaking of, I was watching coverage of the shooting in Tucson and there was a poster of the little girl who was killed and someone had written, "God Needed Another Angel" under her picture and I just about lost my shit. As if God sent a lunatic out in the world to shoot up innocent people just so he could increase an angel population? HOW is that a comforting idea? |
3 |
| 2 |
022a - Birthing a Dying Child (comment)I must sit and chew on this for a while before I can articulate how my experiences sit with me. I'm still new to this. And old to this. Sixteen months ago I birthed Beckett. And 4 months ago I birthed Sullivan. And I had to introduce these cold, dead and beautiful boys to my living children and show them that no matter what life gives us we still can survive. I don't know how to do this on a number of days, but I do. I don't hate God through all of this. Over the past 8 years he/she and I have found a very different, yet closer, relationship than that I was taught in my Christian upbringing. And the verse that I cling to even now is my life mantra. Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death I will fear no evil. I'm there. I am IN that valley. Every day for the rest of my life I will either be in it, stumbling up the side, laying at the bottom of it sobbing or looking down into it as I walk along the edge. And yet I feel a peace and comfort that is so much bigger than me...a peace that passes ALL understanding. |
2 |
| 4 |
022b - am I the only one?Thanks, girls. It's always so tremendously interesting to hear all of the different takes on afterlife and the like. It never really took much energy, but now that I have two children there it takes up much more. I wonder more, watch the sky more, read more. I'm not looking for an answer, just have a little more (hell, a LOT more) invested in that whole idea. |
4 |
|
4 comforted by chaos; another negative example of code 4, even though same argument could be used by religious person ("When Bad Things Happen to Good People") |
023a - when undeserving creeps have babiesSCM - have you read that book [When Bad Things Happen to Good People]? I'm reading it now and it's actually making so much sense. I didn't think I would get that much out of it because I'm not really that religious and not even sure if I believe in God. So I don't feel let down by "Him" so to speak. But the book still makes a great arguement for chaos and how random our universe really is. Looking at the big picture helps me. I can't think in terms of fairness if it really has nothing to do with me. So I'll keep telling myself that... |
4 |
|
4 not religious, but still hoping for afterlife |
023b - am I the only one?Have you guys ever seen the TV show, Dead Like Me? It's about a girl who was killed when she was 18 and was given an assignment in her afterlife to take the souls of people who were about to die before the soul got "stuck" in the dead body. It's a whole theory, I guess, of an afterlife. Anyway, on one episode, the main character had to take the soul of a little girl and obviously had a hard time with it. She eventually did and when the little girl's soul was released, a beautiful carnival of lights appeared in the distance. The little girl ran towards it excitedly and that was the ending. I like the idea that every person's soul goes to the place that makes them happiest. So I like your idea, Julie. I hope wherever our babies are, they're happy. I don't necessarily feel like I'll see Olivia again someday either (outside of my dreams) but who knows? It makes me feel good to think about and that's all that matters now. |
4 |
| 2 |
023c - reading recommendationsWhen Bad Things Happen to Good People, by Harold Kushner - I'm reading this one now and it's really been a great book for me. Like what scm said about Healing Through Dark Emotions, it's making me understand that my own loss is a natural part of life. The big picture helps keep things in perspective. It's also prompted me to reconsider my previous views on God and religion which is helpful on another level. Lifetimes, by Bryon Mellonie - I bought this to help explain death to my 3 year old and found it very comforting, as well. "There is a beginning and an ending for everything that is alive. In between is living." Regardless of how short her life was, it was a life and that means a lot to me. She was real and I loved her. Will always love her. |
2 |
|
4 rejecting notion of karma (that parent deserved loss for her misteps) as reason for baby's death |
024a - The Inescapability of Karma--Maybe (comment)I sought therapy after Gabriel died, conventional talk therapy with a psychologist I had seen before. (I'm an old hat at therapy.) For me it was a space to let my grief really rage, to be all-consuming. I started therapy about the same time that I started back to freelancing, which was a sign of moving forward with life — which as we all know is a difficult choice to make. My therapist was great, letting me work through my thoughts, fears, pain. I don't recall a particularlly difficult section, although there was a poem I had written that we talked a lot about in the context of losing my son. I never applied the idea of karma as it is presented here to our loss. Although I do firmly believe in 'what comes around goes around' I think because I am so rooted in my Catholic faith I just never felt our loss was retribution for anything. And, believe me, I have the perfect sins for which it could be retribution. But I don't believe God works that way. God is far outside of human understanding, and to say, "he/she is punishing me for X or testing me" is attributing too human motivations to an entity outside of the human realm. I also never bought into "everything happens for a reason". which is not to say that I have not received/sussed out the gifts of my son's life. But a reason? that I just can't fathom. |
2 |
| 4 |
024b - am I the only one?My husband fully believes he will see and hold Gabriel — a live Gabriel; while i believe we will be reunited, I think it kind of doesn't matter if there is a physicality to it or not. I firmly believe in an afterlife, and I think it's being reunited with those who have gone before us as well as with G-d. i like the idea of my son with other children, though, and I also really believe he looks out for us. I pray to him to intercede for us, and to look out for his sisters down here. Especially my wild 3yo. |
4 |
| 4 |
024c - tough as nails (comment)Oh, my, goodness. I suffer from constant anxiety. I am currently on vacation, freaking out about every man who comments how cute my girls are. My therapist diagnosed me with catrostrophic thinking as part -- a major part -- of my Generalized Anxiety Disorder. DearDR, my husband, said he had never seen me more at peace than with my pregnancy with Gabriel. And happy -- so happy. Not that I am not happy now, but it is tempered with anxiety. It's terrible. The only things that allowed us to move forward were our desire to be a mommy and a daddy, and our faith in God. That's it. Without one of those, we would have never had moved on. Well, therapy helped. a lot. |
4 |
| 1 |
025a - HatredI hate god , myself , fate , my body or whatever it was that stole my sons life. Damn you. Damn you. Damn you. Why am I here crying and pleading for the safe return of my son, why am I not in hospital right now giving birth like I should be. What do you expect me to do with my life, freddies nursery, his little hat, his bear suit and tiny little boots. Did I not try my best, did I not fight and beg you enough for mercy, what did u want in exchange for my son? whatever it was u know I would have u given you so why did u take him! I hate you. I hate you. I hate you |
1 |
| 1 |
025b - so sick of death...just sick of itI hear you. It's just never ending. When the hell is the angel of death, god or whatever it is leading us on this path of destruction, finally going to decide that enough is enough, that your heart, soul and mind have shattered into enough pieces, that all of us have lost our babies and are already broken beyond repair. What more are we meant to do or give an to what end. Hang in there Ryder Lees Momma, thinking of you and Ryder Lee. Let us know how you are doing. |
1 |
| 1, 3 |
026a - dealing with lifehey Christy, |
1 |
| 1 |
026b - prayers needed for Auggieoh Jill s,im so sorry for what you're going through,it breaks my heart to know that after everything you've been through you also have to go through this,it seems so unfair and these are the things that pulls us further and further away from this unjust god *if there is such a thing*, i will however just for a few minutes pray for your son,i'm giving it my last short bc you deserve to have your son in your arms. You and Steph deserve to have your babies in your arms. You are in my thoughts and prayer (i'l pray jst this 1 time). |
1 |
|
4 concern for afterlife of child; also willing to bargain with "the devil" to get baby back |
026c - feeling so alonethank you ladies for your advise, it gets harder for me by the day,for some reason i have some hope that my son might come back and be with me. Has anyne considered selling their souls to the devel in exchange of their dead babies?well,i'm trying to make that deal but like God it seems like the devil himself is even ignoring me, can you believe,i'm offering somethinng of quality here,my soul bt even the devil ignores me. I know i sound crazy bt i have to have hope that my son might come back i just have to or else i will follow him whereever he is,i'd rather spend eternity in hell but at least have some time with my son,have an oppportunity to feed him and watch him grow up. |
4 |
| 3 |
027a - dear friend (comment)"Never say that everything happens for a reason. Never try to mollify them with talk of angels and meant-to-be's. Never say that God works in mysterious ways." Yes, yes, and yes! I'm a follower of Christ, but every time (and there were many times) someone said something stupid like this, I had the decidedly un-Christian urge to punch them in the nose. |
3 |
| 1 |
027b - welcome to the cabinAlmost eight months ago my baby girl was born prematurely due to (what I now refer to as) my stupid incompetent cervix. She lived for fifteen minutes in my arms before silently slipping into the next world. I have been coping and managing very well up until now. Now I am 20 weeks pregnant with my second child, and as 22 weeks and 4 days approaches, I descend into irrational hysteria with very little provocation. I weep more or as much as I did in the days and weeks after her death. I can't believe that this or anyone else's pregnancy will result in the birth of a baby who lives and gets to go home. I am a faithful person, and I try to put my trust in God, but I feel so desperately that he let me down when my baby died. I have been scouring the web over the last week, secretly searching for... something. My husband thinks it is unhealthy for me to be looking at blog and websites about other people's dead babies. But I think that I am looking for others who know my story. Those I can just sit with, with my hands wrapped around a warm mug, and we don't have to say anything, because we just KNOW. Thank you for being a place where I can be a babylost mama. |
1 |
| 1 |
027c - Strength in the Ashes (comment)I sit here in my warm, cozy cabin, my brand new son asleep on my chest. My heart is full with the many blessings I have received in my life. My new son, C, is healthy and beautiful, |
1 |
|
2, 4 restoration and growth in faith; comfort in afterlife for baby |
027d - One Day at Suppertime (comment)I have been doing really well lately. When my son pulled up on the shelf next to our bed and pointed to his sister's picture and said, "that?" I was able to say with a steady voice, "that's your sister, honey." I can think of my brief time with her in my arms and not weep, and I can believe honestly and hopefully of being reunited with her in heaven. I have been healing spiritually as well. I wasn't able to read my Bible or pray without losing it and feeling great anger toward God. But I'm back in a place of relationship with God, and while it's tentative and healing, it's real, and it's growing. So, I'm doing really well. I had the epiphany that I was doing well, and then on Monday a friend of mine emailed to ask how I was doing because I's birthday had just passed. I wrote back to her and thanked her for asking, and I told her that meant so much to me that she remembered my little girl. In the process of writing this note, I burst into tears...and at that exact moment the new neighbor came over to introduce herself. She didn't ask, and I didn't share, but goodness, what must she think of me! Then the next day I took my son to the pediatrician, and a new nurse came to give him his injections. We were chatting, and she asked if my son was my first...and I burst into tears. I don't know why it hit me at that exact moment. I explained to her why I was crying, and she started crying, too, and she told me she was also a babylost mama. Her baby boy died 23 year ago, and she still wept for him. She said, "you never get over it, honey. They will always be our babies." I think that we just learn how to live every day without suffocating in our grief, but there will always be those days, or those moments when we remember our babies and weep...and that will be okay. |
2 |
| 4 |
027e - Time and AgainMy first child died less than a year ago. She was born just shy of 23 weeks and lived for fifteen minutes as her father and I sang to her, held her, had her baptized, and kissed her as she died. It was a terrible, terrible experience. I am pregnant again, and it is terrifying. I am currently at 30 weeks, so if this child were born tomorrow chances of survival would be very high, but I still live in a state of worry. When I haven't felt him/her move for a while, when he/she moves too much, when something just doesn't feel right, I worry. I don't think I am allowing myself to believe that I will bring home a live baby this time around. Any time I don't feel the baby move, I start imagining what the funeral will need to be like and whether or not there is a plot near I's grave. And then I remind myself of the God I believe in, and I do kick counts, and then I can breathe again. On one hand I am resentful that my innocence has been lost. But on the other hand I am thankful that I take nothing for granted with this pregnancy. Each milestone and each moment is a big deal and something to be celebrated. In fact, I am lying in bed right now watching my belly shift with the baby's movement, and I am in awe. I never was able to experience this with his/her big sister. I take this pregnancy day by day, and sometimes minute by minute. I don't know if I will ever be able to do this again, but I am doing it now. |
2 |
|
3, 4 desiring to say something to the religious community, to correct bad theology |
028a - PerfectDear heart: I don't think God was any more impressed with her reasoning than you were. What a garbage response, attributing a nasty lie to God and disparaging your daughter's worth in one feel swoop. How dare she. God doesn't love us because we're perfect. He loves us because he is. And he loves that darling, priceless, wonderful, beautiful, unique, carefully formed, delightful little sweetheart your womb grew for so many months. It's always the Pharisee types who attribute their own ugly, sad views to God to make themselves feel better at everyone else's expense. Jesus, on the other hand, was too busy having dinner with the untouchable castoffs or weeping with those in pain to beat people up with misquoted, misapplied, twisted-beyond-all-recognition "Thus saith the Lord" statements. He saved his anger for the "religious" types who were too puffed up on their own sanctity to lend a hand to people in need. (And now I'm mad on your behalf...so sorry she used your pain as an opportunity to make herself feel better rather than braving the discomfort of sitting with you in the reality of the incomprehensible loss of your precious daughter. Because that's what you--and she--deserve.) |
3 |